VALUATION OF NUMERAL CANCELS

 

In 1958, C. Versteeg, MSc, published a list of valuations of the Dutch Indies numeral cancels in 'de Postzak'. He composed this list on the basis of an investigation of the gross sales generated by the post offices during the years that the cancels were in use. The gross sales was determined on the basis of the sale of postage stamps, postal stationery and postage due stamps. Versteeg assigned a valuation to the numeral cancel of a given post office, on the basis of its gross sales, for the 10 ct Scott 9 (The 10 cent King William III from the 1870 emission). 

This website presents the research done by five collectors to assess the relative scarcity of each of the post-offices on the basis of five large collections of numeral cancels. By averaging  the valuations of Versteeg (each point is one Euro) with the results of the research, a new valuation list was obtained. For a few offices, the differences between Versteeg and the research were large, and small corrections (often downwards) were made. 

It is not the intent to replace Peter Storm van Leeuwen's valuation list in the NVPH Specialiteiten Catalogus 2006-2011. Rather, the new valuation list is designed to arrive at a proportion-based valuation, derived from examination of records (the annual reports) and field work (analysis of five large collections). 

Empirical research was starting point for Peter Storm van Leeuwen's list. The proportions established by the investigations of Versteeg and Kruse are the starting point for the new valuation list. The largest differences are mainly limited to the scarcest offices, which in my opinion deserve a higher valuation. 

The valuations for stamps other than Scott 9 include a multiplier; the market value of the stamp must be added to the product. 

All attempts to arrive at a valuation are subject to criticism. Therefore, the following list is meant as a guide, and not as an absolute measure of value. Comments are always welcome.

For the valuations on Postal Stationery and Covers you will find a good reference in the "Specialiteiten Catalous 2006-2011" by Peter Strom van Leeuwen.

 

Nr. Post office Island Euro
1 Weltevreden Java 0,50
2 Samarang Java 0,50
3 Soerabaija Java 0,50
4 Batavia Java 0,50
5 Padang Sumatra 0,50
6 Cheribon Java 1,50
7 Soerakarta Java 1,00
8 Buitenzorg Java 1,00
9 Makassar Celebes 1,00
10 Djokjakarta Java 1,50
11 Passoeroean Java 1,00
12 Bandong Java 1,50
13 Tagal Java 1,50
14 Pekalongan Java 2,00
15 Salatiga Java 2,00
16 Ambarawa Java 2,00
17 Pattie Java 5,00
18 Rembang Java 3,50
19 Toeban Java 7,50
20 Banjoemas Java 3,50
21 Tjilatjap Java 6,00
22 Poerworedjo Java 3,50
23 Magelang Java 1,50
24 Madioen Java 3,50
25 Grissee Java 10,00
26 Probolingo Java 2,00
27 Bezoekie Java 6,00
28 Banjoewangie Java 5,00
29 Kedirie Java 2,50
30 Pamakassan Madoera 12,50
31 Bandjermasin Borneo 2,00
32 Palembang Sumatra 2,50
33 Amboina Molukken 5,00
34 Riouw Sumatra 7,50
35 Muntok Banka 5,00
36 Pontianak Borneo 3,50
37 Serang Java 6,00
38 Anjer Java 15,00
39 Poerwakarta Java 12,50
40 Meester Cornelis Java 2,00
41 Tjiandjoer Java 6,00
42 Sumedang Java 7,50
43 Indramaijoe Java 7,50
44 Tjiamis Java 35,00
45 Kendal Java 5,00
46 Koedoes Java 7,50
47 Bodjonegoro Java 10,00
48 Klatten Java 5,00
49 Ngawie Java 7,50
50 Patjitan Java 30,00
51 Modjokerto Java 3,50
52 Malang Java 2,50
53 Sitoebondo Java 6,00
54 Sumanap Madoera 10,00
55 Fort de Kock Sumatra 5,00
56 Sibogha Sumatra 10,00
57 Benkoelen Sumatra 6,00
58 Telokbetong Sumatra 12,50
59 Bengkalis Sumatra 10,00
60 Tandjongpandan Billiton 10,00
60 Billiton Billiton  
61 Poerwadadi Java 10,00
61 Singkawang Borneo  
62 Menado Celebes 3,00
63 Ternate Molukken 7,50
64 Banda  Molukken 5,00
65 Timor Soenda Eil. 10,00
66,1 Veldpost Atjeh no 1 Sumatra 50,00
66,2 Veldpost Atjeh  Sumatra 2,50
66,2 Kotaradja Sumatra  
66,2 Atjeh Sumatra  
67 Oenarang Java 10,00
67 Veldpost Atjeh no 2 Sumatra  
68 Padangpandjang Sumatra 2,50
68 Veldpost Atjeh no 3 Sumatra  
69,1 Karanganjar Java 35,00
69,1 Exp.kant. Bat. Mi. Str. Postagent  
69,2 Demak Java 10,00
70 Blitar Java 2,50
71 Loemadjang Java 6,00
72 Bondowosso Java 6,00
73 Boijolalie Java 15,00
74 Kottaboemi Sumatra 500,00
75 Moearadoewa Sumatra 50,00
76 Tebingtinggi Sumatra 15,00
77 Lahat Sumatra 10,00
78 Seblat Sumatra 85,00
79 Mokko Mokko Sumatra 100,00
80 Indrapoera Sumatra 65,00
81 Rau Sumatra 15,00
81 Loeboesikaping Sumatra  
82 Padangsidempoean Sumatra 5,00
83 Singkel Sumatra 40,00
84 Deli Sumatra 1,50
84 Laboean Sumatra  
84 Laboean Deli Sumatra  
85 Sidhoaradjo Java 7,50
86 Japara Java 15,00
87 Toeloengagoeng Java 10,00
88 Gorontalo Celebes 15,00
89 NIExpKant.Singapore Postagent 15,00
90 NIExpKant.Penang Postagent 10,00
91 Soekaboemi Java 5,00
92 Bandjarnegara Java 25,00
93 Djember Java 7,50
94 Djoewana Java 7,50
95 Kraksaan Java 6,00
96 Karanganjer Java 10,00
97 Ponorogo Java 30,00
98 Temanggoeng Java 12,50
99 Wonosobo Java 10,00
100,1 Langkat Sumatra 250,00
100,2 Bangkil Java 10,00
101 Baros Sumatra 40,00
102 Garoet Java 6,00
103 Krawang Java 35,00
104 Soebang Java 25,00
105 Olehleh Sumatra 6,00
106 Edi Sumatra 25,00
107 Keboemen Java 30,00
107 Teloksemawe Sumatra  
108 Medan Sumatra 1,00
109 Wlingi Java 12,50
110 Djombang Java 12,50
111 Kalianda Sumatra 200,00
112 Goenoengtoea Sumatra 350,00
113 Tebingtinggideli Sumatra 25,00
113 Bandarklipa Sumatra  
114 Rantauprapat Sumatra 1.350,00
115 Tandjongbalei Sumatra 7,50
116,1 Boeleleng Soenda Eil. 25,00
116,2 Gombong Java 30,00
117,1 Banckalan Madoera 45,00
117,2 Bindjei Sumatra 7,50
118 Tandjongpoera Sumatra 15,00
119 Lasem Java 45,00
120 Toeren Java 25,00

Offices marked in yellow can be identified only by means of the date cancel on the piece of postal stationary in question.

---

VALUATION OF NUMERAL CANCELS ON OTHER STAMPS

It is very difficult to provide a valuation of numeral cancels on stamps other than NVPH 9. To provide somewhat of a valuation rule, the value of the numeral cancel can be multiplied with the factor listed for the stamp. One should add the value of the stamp to the result.

 

Scott Factor
3 and 4 1,9
5 and 6 2,2
7 1,9
8 1,1
9 1,0
10 1,5
11 1,0
12 1,0
13 1,0
14 1,2
15 1,1
16 2,1
17 3,6
18 1,7
19 1,5
20 2,5
21 1,2
22 1,2
   
Postage Due  
j3 6,0
j4 4,8
j5 3,8
j6 1,6
j7 2,4
j8 1,8
j9 1,9
j10 2,9
j11 1,0
j12 5,0
j13 3,1
j14 4,0
j15 4,5

A calculation example:
Assume we have numeral cancel 56 of Sibogha on Scott 16. The cancel is worth 2.1 x Euro 10.00 = Euro 21.00. Euro 7.50 should be added for the market value (this is an estimate) of the stamp.
The total value of the combination is than Euro 28.50

For an overview of all samps: see the catalogue

 

R-index
Articles on this website contain a Rarity-index (in Dutch).